    Appendix C
    Technical notes
    This appendix describes how the U. S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) collects, estimates, and
    reports electric power data in the EPM.

    Data quality
    The EPM is prepared by the Office of Energy Production, Conversion & Delivery (EPCD), Energy
    Information Administration (EIA), U.S. Department of Energy. Quality statistics begin with the collection
    of the correct data. To assure this, EPCD performs routine reviews of the data collected and the forms
    on which it is collected. Additionally, to assure that the data are collected from the correct parties,
    EPCD routinely reviews the frames for each data collection.

    Automatic, computerized verification of keyed input, review by subject matter specialists, and follow‐up
    with nonrespondents assure quality statistics. To ensure the quality standards established by the EIA,
    formulas that use the past history of data values in the database have been designed and implemented
    to check data input for errors automatically. Data values that fall outside the ranges prescribed in the
    formulas are verified by telephoning respondents to resolve any discrepancies. All survey
    nonrespondents are identified and contacted.

    Reliability of data
    There are two types of errors possible in an estimate based on a sample survey: sampling and non‐
    sampling. Sampling errors occur because observations are made only on a sample, not on the entire
    population. Non‐sampling errors can be attributed to many sources in the collection and processing of
    data. The accuracy of survey results is determined by the joint effects of sampling and non‐sampling
    errors. Monthly sample survey data have both sampling and non‐sampling error. Annual survey data
    are collected by a census and are not subject to sampling error.

    Non‐sampling errors can be attributed to many sources: (1) inability to obtain complete information
    about all cases in the sample (i.e., nonresponse); (2) response errors; (3) definitional difficulties; (4)
    differences in the interpretation of questions; (5) mistakes in recording or coding the data obtained; and
    (6) other errors of collection, response, coverage, and estimation for missing data. Note that for the
    cutoff sampling and model‐based regression (ratio) estimation that we use, data ‘missing’ due to
    nonresponse, and data ‘missing’ due to being out‐of‐sample are treated in the same manner. Therefore
    missing data may be considered to result in sampling error, and variance estimates reflect all missing
    data.

    Although no direct measurement of the biases due to non‐sampling errors can be obtained,
    precautionary steps were taken in all phases of the frame development and data collection, processing,
    and tabulation processes, in an effort to minimize their influence. See the Data Processing and Data
    System Editing section for each EIA form for an in‐depth discussion of how the sampling and non‐
    sampling errors are handled in each case.
    Relative Standard Error: The relative standard error (RSE) statistic, usually given as a percentage,
    describes the magnitude of sampling error that might reasonably be incurred. The RSE is the square

U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                      Page 1
    root of the estimated variance, divided by the variable of interest. The variable of interest may be the
    ratio of two variables, or a single variable.

    The sampling error may be less than the non‐sampling error. In fact, large RSE estimates found in
    preliminary work with these data have often indicated non‐sampling errors, which were then identified
    and corrected. Non‐sampling errors may be attributed to many sources, including the response errors,
    definitional difficulties, differences in the interpretation of questions, mistakes in recording or coding
    data obtained, and other errors of collection, response, or coverage. These non‐sampling errors also
    occur in complete censuses.

    Using the Central Limit Theorem, which applies to sums and means such as are applicable here, there is
    approximately a 68 percent chance that the true total or mean is within one RSE of the estimated total
    or mean. Note that reported RSEs are always estimates themselves, and are usually, as here, reported as
    percentages. As an example, suppose that a net generation from coal value is estimated to be 1,507
    million kilowatthours with an estimated RSE of 4.9 percent. This means that, ignoring any non‐sampling
    error, there is approximately a 68 percent chance that the true million kilowatthour value is within
    approximately 4.9 percent of 1,507 million kilowatthours (that is, between 1,433 and 1,581 million
    kilowatthours). Also under the Central Limit Theorem, there is approximately a 95 percent chance that
    the true mean or total is within 2 RSEs of the estimated mean or total.

    Note that there are times when a model may not apply, such as in the case of a substantial
    reclassification of sales, when the relationship between the variable of interest and the regressor data
    does not hold. In such a case, the new information may represent only itself, and such numbers are
    added to model results when estimating totals. Further, there are times when sample data may be
    known to be in error, or are not reported. Such cases are treated as if they were never part of the
    model‐based sample, and values are imputed. Experiments were done to see if nonresponse should be
    treated differently, but it was decided to treat those cases the same as out‐of‐sample cases.

    Relative Standard Error With Respect to a Superpopulation: The RSESP statistic is similar to the RSE
    (described above). Like the RSE, it is a statistic designed to estimate the variability of data and is usually
    given as a percentage. However, where the RSE is only designed to estimate the magnitude of sampling
    error, the RSESP more fully reflects the impact of variability from sampling and non‐sampling errors.
    This is a more complete measure than RSE in that it can measure statistical variability in a complete
    census in addition to a sample 21,24. In addition to being a measure of data variability, the RSESP can
    also be useful in comparing different models that are applied to the same set of data22. This capability
    is used to test different regression models for imputation and prediction. This testing may include
    considerations such as comparing different regressors, the comparative reliability of different monthly
    samples, or the use of different geographical strata or groupings for a given model. For testing
    purposes, EPCD typically uses recent historical data that have been finalized. Typically, time‐series
    graphics showing two or more models or samples are generated showing the RSESP values over time. In
    selecting models, consideration is given to total survey error as well as any apparent differences in
    robustness.




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                          Page 2
    Imputation: For monthly data, if the reported values appeared to be in error and the data issue could
    not be resolved with the respondent, or if the facility was a nonrespondent, a regression methodology is
    used to impute for the facility. The same procedure is used to estimate ("predict") data for facilities not
    in the monthly sample. The regression methodology relies on other data to make estimates for
    erroneous or missing responses.

    Estimation for missing monthly data is accomplished by relating the observed data each month to one or
    more other data elements (regressors) for which we generally have an annual census. Each year, when
    new annual regressor data are available, recent monthly relationships are updated, causing slight
    revisions to estimated monthly results. These revisions are made as soon as the annual data are
    released.

    The basic technique employed is described in the paper “Model‐Based Sampling and Inference16,” on
    the EIA website. Additional references can be found on the InterStat website
    (http://interstat.statjournals.net/). The basis for the current methodology involves a 'borrowing of
    strength' technique for small domains.

    Data revision procedure
    EPCD has adopted the following policy with respect to the revision and correction of recurrent data in
    energy publications:

              Annual survey data are disseminated either as preliminary or final when first appearing in a data
               product. Data initially released as preliminary will be so noted in the data product. These data
               are typically released as final by the next dissemination of the same product; however, if final
               data are available at an earlier interval they may be released in another product.
              All monthly survey data are first disseminated as preliminary. These data are revised after the
               prior year’s data are finalized and are disseminated as revised preliminary. No revisions are
               made to the published data before this or subsequent to these data being finalized unless
               significant errors are discovered.
              After data are disseminated as final, further revisions will be considered if they make a
               difference of 1 percent or greater at the national level. Revisions for differences that do not
               meet the 1 percent or greater threshold will be determined by the Office Director. In either
               case, the proposed revision will be subject to the EIA revision policy concerning how it affects
               other EIA products.
              The magnitudes of changes due to revisions experienced in the past will be included periodically in
               the data products, so that the reader can assess the accuracy of the data.

    Data sources for Electric Power Monthly
    Data published in the EPM are compiled from the following sources:

              Form EIA‐923, “Power Plant Operations Report,”
              Form EIA 826, “Monthly Electric Utility Sales and Revenues with State Distributions Report,”
              Form EIA 860, “Annual Electric Generator Report,”
              Form EIA‐860M, “Monthly Update to the Annual Electric Generator Report,” and


U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                          Page 3
              Form EIA 861, “Annual Electric Power Industry Report.”

    For access to these forms and their instructions, please see:
    http://www.eia.gov/cneaf/electricity/page/forms.html.

    In addition to the above‐named forms, the historical data published in the EPM for periods prior to 2008
    are compiled from the following sources:

              FERC Form 423, “Monthly Report of Cost and Quality of Fuels for Electric Plants,”
              Form EIA‐423, “Monthly Cost and Quality of Fuels for Electric Plants Report,”
              Form EIA‐759, “Monthly Power Plant Report,”
              Form EIA‐860A, “Annual Electric Generator Report–Utility,”
              Form EIA‐860B, “Annual Electric Generator Report–Nonutility,”
              Form EIA‐900, “Monthly Nonutility Power Report,”
              Form EIA‐906, “Power Plant Report,” and
              Form EIA‐920, “Combined Heat and Power Plant Report.”

    See Appendix A of the historical Electric Power Annual reports to find descriptions of forms that are no
    longer in use. The publications can be found from the top of the current EPA under previous issues:
    http://www.eia.gov/electricity/annual.

    Rounding rules for data: To round a number to n digits (decimal places), add one unit to the nth digit if
    the (n+1) digit is 5 or larger and keep the nth digit unchanged if the (n+1) digit is less than 5. The symbol
    for a number rounded to zero is (*).

    Percent difference: The following formula is used to calculate percent differences:


                                                                      𝑥(𝑡 ) − 𝑥(𝑡 )
                                               𝑃𝑒𝑟𝑐𝑒𝑛𝑡 𝐷𝑖𝑓𝑓𝑒𝑟𝑒𝑛𝑐𝑒 =                 𝑥100
                                                                         |𝑥(𝑡 )|

    where x (t1) and x (t2) denote the quantity at year t1 and subsequent year t2.


    Meanings of symbols appearing in tables: The following symbols have the meaning described below:

    P          Indicates a preliminary value.

    NM         Data value is not meaningful, either (1) when compared to the same value for the previous time
               period, or (2) when a data value is not meaningful due to having a high Relative Standard Error
               (RSE).




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                         Page 4
    Form EIA‐826
    The Form EIA 826, “Monthly Electric Utility Sales and Revenues with State Distributions Report,” is a
    monthly collection of data from a sample of approximately 500 of the largest electric utilities (primarily
    investor owned and publicly owned) as well as a census of energy service providers with sales to
    ultimate consumers in deregulated States. Form EIA‐861, with approximately 3,300 respondents, serves
    as a frame from which the Form 826 sample is drawn. Based on this sample, a model is used to estimate
    for the entire universe of U.S. electric utilities.

    Instrument and design history: The collection of electric power sales data and related information
    began in the early 1940’s and was established as FPC Form 5 by FPC Order 141 in 1947. In 1980, the
    report was revised with only selected income items remaining and became the FERC Form 5. The Form
    EIA 826, “Electric Utility Company Monthly Statement,” replaced the FERC Form 5 in January 1983. In
    January 1987, the “Electric Utility Company Monthly Statement” was changed to the “Monthly Electric
    Utility Sales and Revenue Report with State Distributions.” The title was changed again in January 2002
    to “Monthly Electric Utility Sales and Revenues with State Distributions Report” to become consistent
    with other EIA report titles. The Form EIA 826 was revised in January 1990, and some data elements
    were eliminated.

    In 1993, EIA for the first time used a model sample for the Form EIA 826. A stratified random sample,
    employing auxiliary data, was used for each of the four previous years. The sample for the Form EIA 826
    was designed to obtain estimates of electricity sales and average price of electricity to ultimate
    consumers at the State level by end use sector.

    Starting with data for January 2001, the restructuring of the electric power industry was taken into
    account by forming three schedules on the Form EIA‐826. Schedule 1, Part A is for full service utilities
    that operate as in the past. Schedule 1, Part B is for electric service providers only, and Schedule 1, Part
    C is for those utilities providing distribution service for those on Schedule 1, Part B. In addition, Schedule
    1 Part D is for those energy providers to ultimate consumers or power marketers that provide bundled
    service. Also, the Form EIA‐826 frame was modified to include all investor‐owned electric utilities and a
    sample of companies from other ownership classes. A new method of estimation was implemented at
    this same time. (See EPM April 2001, p.1.)

    With the November 2004 issue of the EPM, EIA published for the first time preliminary electricity sales
    data for the Transportation Sector. These data are for electricity delivered to and consumed by local,
    regional, and metropolitan transportation systems. The data being published for the first time in the
    October EPM included July 2004 data as well as year‐to‐date. EIA’s efforts to develop these new data
    have identified anomalies in several States and the District of Columbia. Some of these anomalies are
    caused by issues such as: 1) Some respondents have classified themselves as outside the realm of the
    survey. The Form EIA‐826 collects data from those respondents providing electricity and other services
    to the ultimate end users. EIA has experienced specific situations where, although the respondents’
    customers are the ultimate end users, particular end users qualify under wholesale rate schedules. 2)
    The Form EIA‐826 is a cutoff sample and not intended to be a census.




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                         Page 5
    Beginning with 2008 data and some annual 2007 data, the Form EIA‐923 replaced Forms EIA‐906, EIA‐
    920, EIA‐423, and FERC 423. In addition, several sections of the discontinued Form EIA‐767 have been
    included in either the Form EIA‐860 or Form EIA‐923. See the following link for a detailed explanation.
    http://www.eia.gov/cneaf/electricity/2008forms/consolidate.html

    The legislative authority to collect these data is defined in the Federal Energy Administration Act of 1974
    (Public Law 93‐275, Sec. 13(b), 5(a), 5(b), 52).

    Data processing and data system editing: Monthly Form EIA‐826 submission is available via an Internet
    Data Collection (IDC) system. The completed data are due to EIA by the last calendar day of the month
    following the reporting month. Nonrespondents are contacted to obtain the data. The data are edited
    and additional checks are completed. Following verification, imputation is run, and tables and text of
    the aggregated data are produced for inclusion in the EPM.

    Imputation: Regression prediction, or imputation, is done for entities not in the monthly sample and for
    any nonrespondents. Regressor data for Schedule 1, Part A is the average monthly sales or revenue
    from the most recent finalized data from survey Form EIA‐861. Beginning with January 2008 data and
    the finalized 2007 data, the regressor data for Schedule 1 Parts B and C is the prior month’s data.

    Formulas and methodologies: The Form EIA 826 data are collected by end‐use sector (residential,
    commercial, industrial, and transportation) and State. Form EIA 861 data are used as the frame from
    which the sample is selected and in some instances also as regressor data. Updates are made to the
    frame to reflect mergers that affect data processing.

    With the revised definitions for the commercial and industrial sectors to include all data previously
    reported as ‘other’ data except transportation, and a separate transportation sector, all responses that
    would formerly have been reported under the “other” sector are now to be reported under one of the
    sectors that currently exist. This means there is probably a lower correlation, in general, between, say,
    commercial Form EIA‐826 data for 2004 and commercial Form EIA‐861 data for 2003 than there was
    between commercial Form EIA‐826 data for 2003 and commercial Form EIA‐861 data for 2002 or earlier
    years, although commercial and industrial definitions have always been somewhat nebulous due to
    power companies not having complete information on all customers.

    Data submitted for January 2004 represent the first time respondents were to provide data specifically
    for the transportation end‐use sector.

    During 2003 transportation data were collected annually through Form EIA‐861. Beginning in 2004 the
    transportation data were collected on a monthly basis via Form EIA‐826. In order to develop an
    estimate of the monthly transportation data for 2003, values for both sales of electricity to ultimate
    customers and revenue from sales of electricity to ultimate customers were estimated using the 2004
    monthly profile for the sales and revenues from the data collected via Form EIA‐826. All monthly non‐
    transportation data for 2003 (i.e. street lighting, etc.), which were previously reported in the “other”
    end‐use sector on the Form EIA‐826 have been prorated into the Commercial and Industrial end‐use
    sectors based on the 2003 Form EIA‐861 profile.



U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                       Page 6
    A monthly distribution factor was developed for the monthly data collected in 2004 (for the months of
    January through November). The transportation sales and revenues for January 2004 were assumed to
    be equivalent to the transportation sales and revenues for November 2004. The monthly distribution
    factors for January through November were applied to the annual values for transportation sales and
    revenues collected via Form EIA‐861 to develop corresponding 2003 monthly values. The eleven month
    estimated totals from January through November 2003 were subtracted from the annual values
    obtained from Form EIA‐861 in order to obtain the December 2003 values.

    Data from the Form EIA‐826 are used to determine estimates by sector at the State, Census division, and
    national level. State level sales and revenues estimates are first calculated. Then the ratio of revenue
    divided by sales is calculated to estimate the price of electricity to ultimate consumers at the State level.
    The estimates are accumulated separately to produce the Census division and U.S. level estimates 1.

    Some electric utilities provide service in more than one State. To facilitate the estimation, the State
    service area is actually used as the sampling unit. For each State served by each utility, there is a utility
    State part, or “State service area.” This approach allows for an explicit calculation of estimates for sales,
    revenue, and average price of electricity to ultimate consumers by end use sector at State, Census
    division, and national level. Estimation procedures include imputation to account for nonresponse. Non‐
    sampling error must also be considered. The non‐sampling error is not estimated directly, although
    attempts are made to minimize the non‐sampling error.

    Average price of electricity to ultimate consumers represents the cost per unit of electricity sold and is
    calculated by dividing electric revenue from ultimate consumers by the corresponding sales of
    electricity. The average price of electricity to ultimate consumers is calculated for all consumers and for
    each end‐use sector.

    The electric revenue used to calculate the average price of electricity to ultimate consumers is the
    operating revenue reported by the electric utility. Operating revenue includes energy charges, demand
    charges, consumer service charges, environmental surcharges, fuel adjustments, and other
    miscellaneous charges. Electric utility operating revenues also include State and Federal income taxes
    and taxes other than income taxes paid by the utility.

    The average price of electricity to ultimate consumers reported in this publication by sector represents a
    weighted average of consumer revenue and sales within sectors and across sectors for all consumers,
    and does not reflect the per kWh rate charged by the electric utility to the individual consumers.
    Electric utilities typically employ a number of rate schedules within a single sector. These alternative
    rate schedules reflect the varying consumption levels and patterns of consumers and their associated
    impact on the costs to the electric utility for providing electrical service.

    Adjusting monthly data to annual data: As a final adjustment based on our most complete data, use is
    made of final Form EIA‐861 data, when available. The annual totals for Form EIA‐826 data by State and
    end‐use sector are compared to the corresponding Form EIA‐861 values for sales and revenue. The ratio
    of these two values in each case is then used to adjust each corresponding monthly value.




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                         Page 7
    Sensitive data: Most of the data collected on the Form EIA‐826 are not considered business sensitive.
    However, revenue, sales, and customer data collected from energy service providers (Schedule 1, Part
    B), which do not also provide energy delivery, are considered business sensitive and must adhere to
    EIA's “Policy on the Disclosure of Individually Identifiable Energy Information in the Possession of the
    EIA” (45Federal Register 59812 (1980)).


    Form EIA‐860
    The Form EIA 860, “Annual Electric Generator Report,” is a mandatory annual census of all existing and
    planned electric generating facilities in the United States with a total generator nameplate capacity of 1
    or more megawatts. The survey is used to collect data on existing power plants and 10 year plans for
    constructing new plants, as well as generating unit additions, modifications, and retirements in existing
    plants. Data on the survey are collected at the generator level. Certain power plant environmental‐
    related data are collected at the boiler level. These data include environmental equipment design
    parameters, boiler air emission standards, and boiler emission controls The Form EIA‐860 is made
    available in January to collect data related to the previous year.

    Instrument and design history: The Form EIA‐860 was originally implemented in January 1985 to collect
    data as of year‐end 1984. It was preceded by several Federal Power Commission (FPC) forms including
    the FPC Form 4, Form 12 and 12E, Form 67, and Form EIA‐411. In January 1999, the Form EIA‐860 was
    renamed the Form EIA‐860A, “Annual Electric Generator Report – Utility” and was implemented to
    collect data from electric utilities as of January 1, 1999.

    In 1989, the Form EIA‐867, "Annual Nonutility Power Producer Report," was initiated to collect plant
    data on unregulated entities with a total generator nameplate capacity of 5 or more megawatts. In
    1992, the reporting threshold of the Form EIA‐867 was lowered to include all facilities with a combined
    nameplate capacity of 1 or more megawatts. Previously, data were collected every 3 years from facilities
    with a nameplate capacity between 1 and 5 megawatts. In 1998, the Form EIA‐867, was renamed Form
    EIA‐860B, "Annual Electric Generator Report – Nonutility." The Form EIA‐860B was a mandatory survey
    of all existing and planned nonutility electric generating facilities in the United States with a total
    generator nameplate capacity of 1 or more megawatts.

    Beginning with data collected for the year 2001, the infrastructure data collected on the Form EIA‐860A
    and the Form EIA‐860B were combined into the new Form EIA‐860 and the monthly and annual versions
    of the Form EIA‐906.

    Starting with 2007, design parameters data formerly collected on Form EIA‐767 were collected on Form
    EIA‐860. These include design parameters associated with certain steam‐electric plants’ boilers, cooling
    systems, flue gas particulate collectors, flue gas desulfurization units, and stacks and flues.

    The Federal Energy Administration Act of 1974 (Public Law 93‐275) defines the legislative authority to
    collect these data.




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                      Page 8
    Estimation of form eia‐860 data: EIA received forms from all 18,151 existing generators in the 2010
    Form EIA‐860 frame, so no imputation was required.

    Prime Movers: The Form EIA‐860 sometimes represents a generator’s prime mover by using the
    abbreviations in the table below.
     Prime Mover Code         Prime Mover Description
             BA               Energy Storage, Battery
             CE               Energy Storage, Compressed Air
             CP               Energy Storage, Concentrated Solar Power
             FW               Energy Storage, Flywheel
             PS               Energy Storage, Reversible Hydraulic Turbine (Pumped Storage)
             ES               Energy Storage, Other
                              Steam Turbine, including nuclear, geothermal and solar steam
              ST
                              (does not include combined cycle)
              GT              Combustion (Gas) Turbine (including jet engine design)
              IC              Internal Combustion Engine (diesel, piston, reciprocating)
              CA              Combined Cycle Steam Part
              CT              Combined Cycle Combustion Turbine Part
              CS              Combined Cycle Single Shaft
              CC              Combined Cycle Total Unit
              HA              Hydrokinetic, Axial Flow Turbine
              HB              Hydrokinetic, Wave Buoy
              HK              Hydrokinetic, Other
                              Hydroelectric Turbine (including turbines associated with
              HY
                              delivery of water by pipeline)
                              Turbines Used in a Binary Cycle (including those used for
              BT
                              geothermal applications)
             PV               Photovoltaic
             WT               Wind Turbine, Onshore
             WS               Wind Turbine, Offshore
             FC               Fuel Cell
             OT               Other




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                    Page 9
    Energy Sources: The Form EIA‐860 sometimes represents the energy sources associated with generators
    by using the abbreviations and/or groupings in the table below.
    Energy Source Grouping                     Energy Source Code    Energy Source Description
                                                      ANT            Anthracite Coal
                                                       BIT           Bituminous Coal
                                                       LIG           Lignite Coal
    Coal                                              SUB            Subbituminous Coal
                                                      SGC            Coal‐Derived Synthesis Gas
                                                                     Waste/Other Coal (including anthracite culm, bituminous gob,
                                                        WC
                                                                     fine coal, lignite waste, waste coal)
                                                                     Distillate Fuel Oil (including diesel, No. 1, No. 2, and No. 4 fuel
                                                        DFO
                                                                     oils)
                                                         JF          Jet Fuel
                                                        KER          Kerosene
                                                        PC           Petroleum Coke
                                                        PG           Gaseous Propane
    Petroleum Products
                                                                     Residual Fuel Oil (including No. 5, and No. 6 fuel oils, and bunker
                                                        RFO
                                                                     C fuel oil)
                                                         SG          Synthesis Gas from Petroleum Coke
                                                                     Waste/Other Oil (including crude oil, liquid butane, liquid
                                                        WO           propane, naphtha, oil waste, re‐refined motor oil, sludge oil, tar
                                                                     oil, or other petroleum‐based liquid wastes)
                                                       BFG           Blast Furnace Gas
    Natural Gas and Other Gases                         NG           Natural Gas
                                                       OG            Other Gas
    Nuclear                                            NUC           Nuclear (including Uranium, Plutonium, and Thorium)
                                                       WAT           Water at a Conventional
                                                (Prime Mover = HY)   Hydroelectric Turbine, and water used in Wave Buoy
    Hydroelectric Conventional
                                                                     Hydrokinetic Technology, Current Hydrokinetic Technology, and
                                                                     Tidal Hydrokinetic Technology
                                                        WAT
    Hydroelectric Pumped Storage                                     Pumping Energy for Reversible (Pumped Storage) Hydroelectric

                                                (Prime Mover = PS)   Turbine
                                                       WDS           Wood/Wood Waste Solids (including paper pellets, railroad ties,
                                                                     utility poles, wood chips, bark, and wood waste solids)
                                                        WDL          Wood Waste Liquids (excluding Black Liquor but including red
    Wood and Wood‐Derived Fuels
                                                                     liquor, sludge wood, spent sulfite liquor, and other wood‐based
                                                                     liquids)
                                                       BLQ           Black Liquor
                                                        AB           Agricultural By‐Products
                                                       MSW           Municipal Solid Waste
                                                       OBG           Other Biomass Gas (including digester gas, methane, and other
                                                                     biomass gases)
    Other Biomass
                                                       OBL           Other Biomass Liquids
                                                       OBS           Other Biomass Solids
                                                        LFG          Landfill Gas
                                                       SLW           Sludge Waste
                                                       SUN           Solar (including solar thermal)
    Other Renewable Energy Sources                     WND           Wind
                                                       GEO           Geothermal
                                                       PUR           Purchased Steam
                                                        WH           Waste heat not directly attributed to a fuel source
    Other Energy Sources                               TDF           Tire‐Derived Fuels
                                                       MWH           Electricity used for energy storage


U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                                                Page 10
              OTH              Other




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly   Page 11
    Sensitive data: The tested heat rate data collected on the Form EIA‐860 are considered business
    sensitive.


    Form EIA‐860M
    The Form EIA 860M, “Monthly Update to the Annual Electric Generator Report,” is a mandatory monthly
    survey that collects data on the status of proposed new generators or changes to existing generators for
    plants that report on Form EIA‐860.

    The Form EIA‐860M has a rolling frame based upon planned changes to capacity as reported on the
    previous Form EIA‐860. Respondents are added to the frame 12 months prior to the expected effective
    date for all new units or expected retirement date for existing units. For all other types of capacity
    changes (including retirements, uprates, derates, repowering, or other modifications), respondents are
    added 1 month prior to the anticipated modification change date. Respondents are removed from the
    frame at the completion of the changes or if the change date is moved back so that the plant no longer
    qualifies to be in the frame. Typically, 150 to 200 utilities per month are required to report for 175 to
    250 plants (including 250 to 400 generating units) on this form. The unit characteristics of interest are
    changes to the previously reported planned operating month and year, prime mover type, capacity, and
    energy sources.

    Instrument and design history: The data collected on Form EIA‐860M was originally collected via phone
    calls at the end of each month. During 2005, the Form EIA‐860M was introduced as a mandatory form
    using the Internet Data Collection (IDC) system.

    The legislative authority to collect these data is defined in the Federal Energy Administration Act of 1974
    (Public Law 93‐275, Sec. 13(b), 5(a), 5(b), 52).

    Data processing and data system editing: Approximately 150 to 200 utilities are requested to provide
    data each month on the Form EIA 860M. These data are collected via the IDC system and automatically
    checked for certain errors. Most of the quality assurance issues are addressed by the respondents as
    part of the automatic edit check process. In some cases, respondents are subsequently contacted about
    their explanatory overrides to the edit checks.

    Sensitive data: Data collected on the Form EIA‐860M are not considered to be sensitive.



    Form EIA‐861
    The Form EIA 861, “Annual Electric Power Industry Report,” is a mandatory census of electric power
    industry participants in the United States. The survey is used to collect information on power sales and
    revenue data from approximately 3,300 respondents. About 3,200 are electric utilities and the
    remainder are nontraditional utilities such as energy service providers or the unregulated subsidiaries of
    electric utilities and power marketers.




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                      Page 12
     Instrument and design history: The Form EIA 861 was implemented in January 1985 for collection of
    data as of year end 1984. The Federal Energy Administration Act of 1974 (Public Law 93 275) defines the
    legislative authority to collect these data.

    Data processing and data system editing: The Form EIA 861 is made available to the respondents in
    January of each year to collect data as of the end of the preceding calendar year. The data are edited
    when entered into the interactive on line system. Internal edit checks are per‐formed to verify that
    current data total across and between schedules, and are comparable to data reported the previous
    year. Edit checks are also performed to compare data reported on the Form EIA 861 and similar data
    reported on the Form EIA 826. Respondents are telephoned to obtain clarification of reported data and
    to obtain missing data.

    Data for the Form EIA 861 are collected at the owner level from all electric utilities including energy
    service providers in the United States, its territories, and Puerto Rico. Form EIA 861 data in this report
    are for the United States only.

    Average price of electricity to ultimate consumers represents the cost per unit of electricity sold and is
    calculated by dividing electric revenue from ultimate consumers by the corresponding sales of
    electricity. The average price of electricity to ultimate consumers is calculated for all consumers and for
    each end‐use sector.

    The electric revenue used to calculate the average price of electricity to ultimate consumers is the
    operating revenue reported by the electric power industry participant. Operating revenue includes
    energy charges, demand charges, consumer service charges, environmental surcharges, fuel
    adjustments, and other miscellaneous charges. Electric power industry participant operating revenues
    also include State and Federal income taxes and other taxes paid by the utility.

    The average price of electricity to ultimate consumers reported in this publication by sector represents a
    weighted average of consumer revenue and sales, and does not equal the per kWh rate charged by the
    electric power industry participant to the individual consumers. Electric utilities typically employ a
    number of rate schedules within a single sector. These alternative rate schedules reflect the varying
    consumption levels and patterns of consumers and their associated impact on the costs to the electric
    power industry participant for providing electrical service.

    Sensitive data: Data collected on the Form EIA‐861 are not considered to be sensitive.



    Form EIA‐923
    Form EIA‐923, “Power Plant Operations Report,” is a monthly collection of data on receipts and cost of
    fossil fuels, fuel stocks, generation, consumption of fuel for generation, and environmental data (e.g.
    emission controls and cooling systems). Data are collected from a monthly sample of approximately
    1,900 plants, which includes a census of nuclear and pumped‐storage hydroelectric plants. In addition
    approximately 4,050 plants, representing all other generators 1 MW or greater, are collected annually.
    In addition to electric power generating plants, respondents include fuel storage terminals without


U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                        Page 13
    generating capacity that receive shipments of fossil fuels for eventual use in electric power generation.
    The monthly data are due by the last day of the month following the reporting period.

    Receipts of fossil fuels, fuel cost and quality information, and fuel stocks at the end of the reporting
    period are all reported at the plant level. Plants that burn organic fuels and have a steam turbine
    capacity of at least 10 megawatts report consumption at the boiler level and generation at the
    generator level. For all other plants, consumption is reported at the prime‐mover level. For these
    plants, generation is reported either at the prime‐mover level or, for noncombustible sources (e.g.
    wind, nuclear), at the prime‐mover and energy source level. The source and disposition of
    electricity is reported annually for nonutilities at the plant level as is revenue from sales for resale.
    Environmental data are collected annually from facilities that have a steam turbine capacity of at
    least 10 megawatts.


    Instrument and design history:

    Receipts and cost and quality of fossil fuels
    On July 7, 1972, the Federal Power Commission (FPC) issued Order Number 453 enacting the New Code
    of Federal Regulations, Section 141.61, legally creating the FPC Form 423. Originally, the form was used
    to collect data only on fossil steam plants, but was amended in 1974 to include data on internal‐
    combustion and combustion‐turbine units. The FERC Form 423 replaced the FPC Form 423 in January
    1983. The FERC Form 423 eliminated peaking units, for which data were previously collected on the
    FPC Form 423. In addition, the generator nameplate capacity threshold was changed from 25
    megawatts to 50 megawatts. This reduction in coverage eliminated approximately 50 utilities and 250
    plants. All historical FPC Form 423 data in this publication were revised to reflect the new generator‐
    nameplate‐ capacity threshold of 50 or more megawatts reported on the FERC Form 423. In January
    1991, the collection of data on the FERC Form 423 was extended to include combined cycle units.
    Historical data have not been revised to include these units. Starting with the January 1993 data, the
    FERC began to collect the data directly from the respondents.

    The Form EIA‐423 was originally implemented in January 2002 to collect monthly cost and quality data
    for fossil fuel receipts from owners or operators of nonutility electricity generating plants. Due to the
    restructuring of the electric power industry, many plants which had historically submitted this
    information for utility plants on the FERC Form 423 (see above) were being transferred to the nonutility
    sector. As a result, a large percentage of fossil fuel receipts were no longer being reported. The Form
    EIA‐423 was implemented to fill this void and to capture the data associated with existing non‐
    regulated power producers. Its design closely followed that of the FERC Form 423.

    Both the Form EIA‐423 and FERC Form 423 were superseded by Schedule 2 of the Form EIA‐923 in
    January of 2008. At the time, the Form EIA‐923 maintained the 50‐megawatt threshold for these data.
    In January 2013, the threshold was changed to 200 megawatts for plants primarily fueled by natural
    gas, petroleum coke, distillate fuel oil, and residual fuel oil. The requirement to report self‐ produced
    and minor fuels, i.e., blast furnace gas, other manufactured gases, kerosene, jet fuel, propane, and
    waste oils was eliminated. The threshold for coal plants remained at 50 megawatts.


U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                          Page 14
    Not all data are collected monthly on the Form EIA‐923. Beginning with 2008 data, a sample of the
    respondents report monthly, with the remainder reporting annually. Until January 2013, monthly fuel
    receipts values for the annual surveys were imputed via regression. Prior to 2008, Schedule 2 annual
    data were not collected or imputed.

    Generation, consumption, and stocks

    The Bureau of Census and the U.S. Geological Survey collected, compiled, and published data on the
    electric power industry prior to 1936. After 1936, the Federal Power Commission (FPC) assumed all
    data collection and publication responsibilities for the electric power industry and implemented the
    Form FPC‐4. The Federal Power Act, Section 311 and 312, and FPC Order 141 defined the legislative
    authority to collect power production data. The Form EIA‐759 replaced the Form FPC‐4 in January
    1982.

    In 1996, the Form EIA‐900 was initiated to collect sales for resale data from unregulated entities14. In
    1998, the form was modified to collect sales for resale, gross generation, and sales to end user data. In
    1999, the form was modified to collect net generation, consumption, and ending stock data15. In
    2000, the form was modified to include the production of useful thermal output data.

    In January 2001, Form EIA‐906 superseded Forms EIA‐759 and EIA‐900. In January 2004, Form EIA‐920
    superseded Form EIA‐906 for those plants defined as combined heat and power plants; all other plants
    that generate electricity continue to report on Form EIA‐906. The Federal Energy Administration Act of
    1974 (Public Law 93‐275) defines the legislative authority to collect these data.

    Forms EIA‐906 and EIA‐920 were superseded by survey Form EIA‐923 beginning in January 2008 with the
    collection of annual 2007 data and monthly 2008 data.


    Data processing and data system editing: Respondents are encouraged to enter data directly into a
    computerized database via the Internet Data Collection (IDC) system. A variety of automated quality
    control mechanisms are run during this process, such as range checks and comparisons with historical
    data. These edit checks are performed as the data are provided, and many problems that are
    encountered are resolved during the reporting process. Those plants that are unable to use the
    electronic reporting medium provide the data in hard copy, typically via fax. These data are manually
    entered into the computerized database. The data are subjected to the same edits as those that are
    electronically submitted.

    If the reported data appear to be in error and the data issue cannot be resolved by follow up contact
    with the respondent, or if a facility is a nonrespondent, a regression methodology is used to impute for
    the facility. Beginning in January 2013, imputation is not performed for fuel receipts data reported on
    Schedule 2.

    Imputation: For select survey data elements collected monthly, regression prediction, or imputation, is
    done for missing data, including non‐sampled units and any non‐respondents. For data collected
    annually, imputation is performed for non‐respondents. For gross generation and total fuel


U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                      Page 15
    consumption, multiple regression is used for imputation (see discussion, above). Only approximately
    0.02 percent of the national total generation for 2010 is imputed, although this will vary by State and
    energy source.

    When gross generation is reported and net generation is not available, net generation is estimated by
    using a fixed ratio to gross generation by prime‐mover type and installed environmental equipment.
    These ratios are:

       Net Generation = (Factor) x Gross Generation

       Prime Movers:
       Combined Cycle Steam ‐ 0.97
       Combined Cycle Single Shaft ‐ 0.97
       Combined Cycle Combustion Turbine ‐ 0.97
       Compressed Air ‐ 0.97
       Fuel Cell ‐ 0.99
       Gas Turbine ‐ 0.98
       Hydroelectric Turbine ‐ 0.99
       Hydroelectric Pumped Storage ‐ 0.99
       Internal Combustion Engine ‐ 0.98
       Other ‐ 0.97
       Photovoltaic ‐ 0.99
       Steam Turbine ‐ 0.97
       Wind Turbine ‐ 0.99

       Environmental Equipment:
       Flue Gas Desulfurization ‐ 0.97
       Flue Gas Particulate 0.99
       All Others ‐ 0.97

    For stocks, a linear combination of the prior month’s ending stocks value and the current month’s
    consumption and receipts values are used.

    Receipts of fossil fuels: Receipts data, including cost and quality of fuels, are collected at the plant level
    from selected electric generating plants and fossil‐fuel storage terminals in the United States. These
    plants include independent power producers, electric utilities, and commercial and industrial combined
    heat and power producers. All plants with a total fossil‐fueled nameplate capacity of 50 megawatts or
    more (excluding storage terminals, which do not produce electricity) were required to report receipts of
    fossil fuels. In January 2013, the threshold was changed to 200 megawatts for plants primarily fueled
    by natural gas, petroleum coke, distillate fuel oil, and residual fuel oil. The requirement to report self‐
    produced and minor fuels, i.e., blast furnace gas, other manufactured gases, kerosene, jet fuel,
    propane, and waste oils was eliminated. The threshold for coal plants remained at 50 megawatts.
    The data on cost and quality of fuel shipments are used to produce aggregates and weighted averages
    for each fuel type at the state, Census division, and U.S. levels.

    For coal, units for receipts are in tons and units for average heat contents (A) are in million Btu per ton.
    For petroleum, units for receipts are in barrels and units for average heat contents (A) are in million Btu
    per barrel.


U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                           Page 16
    For gas, units for receipts are in thousand cubic feet (Mcf) and units for average heat contents (A) are in
    million Btu per thousand cubic foot.

    Power production, fuel stocks, and fuel consumption data: The Bureau of Census and the U.S.
    Geological Survey collected, compiled, and published data on the electric power industry prior to 1936.
    After 1936, the Federal Power Commission (FPC) assumed all data collection and publication
    responsibilities for the electric power industry and implemented the Form FPC‐4. The Federal Power Act,
    Section 311 and 312, and FPC Order 141 defined the legislative authority to collect power production
    data. The Form EIA‐759 replaced the Form FPC‐4 in January 1982.

    In 1996, the Form EIA‐900 was initiated to collect sales for resale data from unregulated entities. In
    1998, the form was modified to collect sales for resale, gross generation, and sales to end user data. In
    1999, the form was modified to collect net generation, consumption, and ending stock data. In 2000, the
    form was modified to include the production of useful thermal output data.

    In January 2001, Form EIA‐906 superseded Forms EIA‐759 and EIA‐900. In January 2004, Form EIA‐920
    superseded Form EIA‐906 for those plants defined as combined heat and power plants; all other plants
    that generate electricity continue to report on Form EIA‐906. The Federal Energy Administration Act of
    1974 (Public Law 93 275) defines the legislative authority to collect these data.

    In January 2004, Form EIA‐920 superseded Form EIA‐906 for those plants defined as combined heat and
    power plants; all other plants that generate electricity continue to report on Form EIA‐906.

    In January 2008, Form EIA‐923 superseded both the Forms EIA‐906 and EIA‐920 for the collection of
    these data.

    Methodology to estimate biogenic and non‐biogenic municipal solid waste2: Municipal solid waste
    (MSW) consumption for generation of electric power is split into its biogenic and non‐biogenic
    components beginning with 2001 data by the following methodology (see Table 1):

    The tonnage of MSW consumed is reported on the Form EIA‐923. The composition of MSW and
    categorization of the components were obtained from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
    (USEPA). For data years 2001 through 2009, the MSW composition was based on the USEPA annual
    publication, Municipal Solid Waste in the United States: Facts and Figures. The compositions
    developed for the 2009 data year were carried forward for the 2010 through 2018 data years. The
    most updated composition and categorization of MSW (for the 2019 data year) were also derived from
    a USEPA publication: Advancing Sustainable Materials Management: Facts and Figures Report: 2015
    Data Tables. The updated composition values were applied in the October EPM 2019 on the preliminary
    2019 values and will be applied going forward in future data years until EIA revises the MSW
    composition ratios again. The Btu contents of the components of MSW were obtained from various
    sources.

    The numbers in Tables 1 and 2 illustrate two interrelated trends in the composition of the MSW
    stream. First, the heat content (per unit weight) of the waste stream has been steadily increasing


U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                       Page 17
    over time due to higher concentrations of non‐biogenic materials. Second, the shares of energy
    contributed to the waste stream by biogenic and non‐biogenic components have been changing
    over time with the percentage of biogenic materials falling and the share of non‐biogenic materials
    rising.

    The potential quantities of combustible MSW discards (which include all MSW material available for
    combustion with energy recovery, discards to landfill, and other disposal) were multiplied by their
    respective Btu contents. The EPA‐based categories of MSW were then classified into renewable and
    non‐renewable groupings. From this, EIA calculated how much of the energy potentially consumed from
    MSW was attributed to biogenic components and how much was attributed to non‐biogenic
    components (see Tables 1 and 2, below). 3

    These values are used to allocate net generation published in the Electric Power Monthly generation
    tables. The tons of biogenic and non‐biogenic components were estimated with the assumption that
    glass and metals were removed prior to combustion. The average Btu/ton for the biogenic and non‐




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                   Page 18
    biogenic components is estimated by dividing the total Btu consumption by the total tons. Published net
    generation attributed to biogenic MSW and non‐biogenic MSW is classified under Other Renewables
    and Other, respectively.

    Table 1. Btu consumption for biogenic and non‐biogenic municipal solid waste (percent)
                   2001      2002      2003      2004     2005    2006   2007   2008   2009   …    2018   2019
    Biogenic        57        56        55        55        56    57      55     54     51    51    51     45
    Non‐            43        44        45        45        44    43      46     46     49    49    49     55
    biogenic


    Table 2. Tonnage consumption for biogenic and non‐biogenic municipal solid waste (percent)
                   2001      2002      2003      2004     2005    2006   2007   2008   2009   …    2018   2019
    Biogenic        77        77        76        76        75    67      65     65     64    64    64     61
    Non‐            23        23        24        24        25    34      35     35     36    36    36     39
    biogenic



    Useful thermal output: With the implementation of the Form EIA‐923, “Power Plant Operations
    Report,” in 2008, combined heat and power (CHP) plants are required to report total fuel consumed and
    electric power generation. Beginning with the January 2008 data, EIA will estimate the allocation of the
    total fuel consumed at CHP plants between electric power generation and useful thermal output.

    First, an efficiency factor is determined for each plant and prime mover type. Based on data for electric
    power generation and useful thermal output collected in 2003 (on Form EIA‐906, “Power Plant Report”)
    efficiency was calculated for each prime mover type at a plant. The efficiency factor is the total output
    in Btu, including electric power and useful thermal output (UTO), divided by the total input in Btu.
    Electric power is converted to Btu at 3,412 Btu per kilowatthour.

    Second, to calculate the amount of fuel for electric power, the gross generation in Btu is multiplied by
    the efficiency factor. The fuel for UTO is the difference between the total fuel reported and the fuel for
    electric power generation. UTO is calculated by multiplying the fuel for UTO by the efficiency factor.

    In addition, if the total fuel reported is less than the estimated fuel for electric power generation, then
    the fuel for electric power generation is equal to the total fuel consumed, and the UTO will be zero.

    Conversion of petroleum coke to liquid petroleum: The quantity conversion is 5 barrels (of 42 U.S.
    gallons each) per short ton (2,000 pounds).

    Conversion of propane gas to liquid petroleum: The quantity conversion is 1.53 Mcf (thousand cubic
    feet) per barrel (or 42 U.S. gallons each).

    Conversion of synthesis gas from coal to coal: The quantity conversion is 98 Mcf (thousand cubic feet)
    per short ton (2,000 pounds).



U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                                 Page 19
    Conversion of synthesis gas from petroleum coke to petroleum coke: The quantity conversion is
    107.42 Mcf (thousand cubic feet) per short ton (2,000 pounds).

    Issues within historical data series:

    Receipts and cost and quality of fossil fuels
    Values for receipts of natural gas for 2001 forward do not include blast furnace gas or other gas.

    Historical data collected on FERC Form 423 and published by EIA have been reviewed for consistency
    between volumes and prices and for their consistency over time. However, these data were collected
    by FERC for regulatory rather than statistical and publication purposes. EIA did not attempt to resolve
    any late filing issues in the FERC Form 423 data. In 2003, EIA introduced a procedure to estimate for late
    or non‐responding entities due to report on the FERC Form 423. Due to the introduction of this
    procedure, 2003 and later data cannot be directly compared to previous years’ data. In January 2013,
    this estimation procedure was dropped.

    Prior to 2008, regulated plants reported receipts data on the FERC Form 423. These plants, along with
    unregulated plants, now report receipts data on Schedule 2 of Form EIA‐923. Because FERC issued
    waivers to the FERC Form 423 filing requirements to some plants who met certain criteria, and because
    not all types of generators were required to report (only steam turbines and combined‐cycle units
    reported), a significant number of plants either did not submit fossil fuel receipts data or submitted only
    a portion of their fossil fuel receipts. Since Form EIA‐923 does not have exemptions based on generator
    type or reporting waivers, receipts data from 2008 and later cannot be directly compared to previous
    years’ data for the regulated sector. Furthermore, there may be a notable increase in fuel receipts
    beginning with January 2008 data.

    Starting with the revised data for 2008, tables for total receipts begin to reflect estimation for all plants
    with capacity over 1 megawatt, to be consistent with other electric power data. Previous receipts data
    published have been a legacy of their original collection as information for a regulatory agency, not as a
    survey to provide more meaningful estimates of totals for statistical purposes. Totals appeared to
    become smaller as more electric production came from unregulated plants, until the Form EIA‐423 was
    created to help fill that gap. As a further improvement, estimation of all receipts for the universe
    normally depicted in the EPM (i.e., 1 megawatt and above), with associated relative standard errors,
    provides a more complete assessment of the market.

    Generation and consumption
    Beginning in 2008, a new method of allocating fuel consumption between electric power generation and
    useful thermal output (UTO) was implemented. This new methodology evenly distributes a combined
    heat and power (CHP) plant’s losses between the two output products (electric power and UTO). In the
    historical data, UTO was consistently assumed to be 80 percent efficient and all other losses at the plant
    were allocated to electric power. This change causes the fuel for electric power to be decreased while
    the fuel for UTO is increased as both are given the same efficiency. This results in the appearance of an
    increase in efficiency of production of electric power between periods.

    Sensitive data: Most of the data collected on the Form EIA‐923 are not considered business sensitive.
    However, the cost of fuel delivered to nonutilities, commodity cost of fossil fuels, and reported fuel
    stocks at the end of the reporting period are considered business sensitive and must adhere to EIA's
U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                         Page 20
    “Policy on the Disclosure of Individually Identifiable Energy Information in the Possession of the EIA”
    (45Federal Register 59812 (1980)).

    Average Capacity Factors
    This section describes the methodology for calculating capacity factors by fuel and technology type for
    operating electric power plants. Capacity factor is a measure (expressed as a percent) of how often an
    electric generator operates over a specific period of time, using a ratio of the actual output to the
    maximum possible output over that period.
    The capacity factor calculation only includes operating electric generators in the Electric Power Sector
    (sectors 1,2, and 3) using the net generation reported on the Form EIA‐923 and the net summer capacity
    reported on the form EIA‐860. The capacity factor for a particular fuel/technology type is given by:


                                                                      ∑ 𝐺𝑒𝑛𝑒𝑟𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛 ,
                    𝐶𝑎𝑝𝑎𝑐𝑖𝑡𝑦 𝐹𝑎𝑐𝑡𝑜𝑟 , = (                                                     )
                                                              ∑ 𝐶𝑎𝑝𝑎𝑐𝑖𝑡𝑦 , × 𝐴𝑣𝑎𝑖𝑙𝑎𝑏𝑙𝑒 𝑇𝑖𝑚𝑒 ,

    Where x represents generators of that fuel/technology combination and m represents the period of
    time (month or year). Generation and capacity are specific to a generator, and the generator is
    categorized by its primary fuel type as reported on the EIA‐860. All generation from that generator is
    included, regardless of other fuels consumed. Available time is also specific to the generator in order to
    account for differing online and retirement dates. Therefore, these published capacity factors will differ
    from a simple calculation using annual generation and capacity totals from the appropriate tables in this
    publication.

    NERC classification
    The Florida Reliability Coordinating Council (FRCC) separated itself from the Southeastern Electric
    Reliability Council (SERC) in the mid‐1990s. In 1998, several utilities realigned from Southwest Power
    Pool (SPP) to SERC. Name changes altered both the Mid‐Continent Area Power Pool (MAPP) to the
    Midwest Reliability Organization (MRO) and the Western Systems Coordinating Council (WSCC) to the
    Western Energy Coordinating Council (WECC). The MRO membership boundaries have altered over
    time, but WECC membership boundaries have not. The utilities in the associated regional entity
    identified as the Alaska System Coordination Council (ASCC) dropped their formal participation in NERC.
    Both the States of Alaska and Hawaii are not contiguous with the other continental States and have no
    electrical interconnections. At the close of calendar year 2005, the following reliability regional councils
    were dissolved: East Central Area Reliability Coordinating Agreement (ECAR), Mid‐Atlantic Area Council
    (MAAC), and Mid‐America Interconnected Network (MAIN).




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                        Page 21
    On January 1, 2006, the ReliabilityFirst Corporation (RFC) came into existence as a new regional
    reliability council. Individual utility membership in the former ECAR, MAAC, and MAIN councils mostly
    shifted to RFC. However, adjustments in membership as utilities joined or left various reliability councils
    impacted MRO, SERC, and SPP. The Texas Regional Entity (TRE) was formed from a delegation of
    authority from NERC to handle the regional responsibilities of the Electric Reliability Council of Texas
    (ERCOT). The revised delegation agreements covering all the regions were approved by the Federal
    Energy Regulatory Commission on March 21, 2008. Reliability Councils that are unchanged include:
    Florida Reliability Coordinating Council (FRCC), Northeast Power Coordinating Council (NPCC), and the
    Western Energy Coordinating Council (WECC

    The new NERC Regional Council names are as follows:

              Florida Reliability Coordinating Council (FRCC),
              Midwest Reliability Organization (MRO),
              Northeast Power Coordinating Council (NPCC),
              ReliabilityFirst Corporation (RFC),
              Southeastern Electric Reliability Council (SERC),
              Southwest Power Pool (SPP),
              Texas Regional Entity (TRE), and
              Western Energy Coordinating Council (WECC).


    Business classification
    Nonutility power producers consist of corporations, persons, agencies, authorities, or other legal entities
    that own or operate facilities for electric generation but are not electric utilities. This includes qualifying
    cogenerators, small power producer, and independent power producers. Furthermore, nonutility power
    producers do not have a designated franchised service area. In addition to entities whose primary
    business is the production and sale of electric power, entities with other primary business classifications
    can and do sell electric power. These can consist of manufacturing, agricultural, forestry,
    transportation, finance, service and administrative industries, based on the Office of Management and
    Budget's Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) Manual. In 1997, the SIC Manual name was changed to
    North American Industry Classification System (NAICS). The following is a list of the main classifications
    and the category of primary business activity within each classification.

    Agriculture, Forestry, and Fishing

    111        Agriculture production‐crops
    112        Agriculture production, livestock and animal specialties
    113        Forestry
    114        Fishing, hunting, and trapping
    115        Agricultural services


    Mining

    211        Oil and gas extraction
    2121       Coal mining
    2122       Metal mining


U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                          Page 22
    2123       Mining and quarrying of nonmetallic minerals except fuels

    Construction

    23

    Manufacturing

    311    Food and kindred products
    3122   Tobacco products
    314    Textile and mill products
    315    Apparel and other finished products made from fabrics and similar materials
    316    Leather and leather products
    321    Lumber and wood products, except furniture
    322    Paper and allied products (other than 322122
           or 32213)
    322122 Paper mills, except building paper
    32213 Paperboard mills
    323    Printing and publishing
    324    Petroleum refining and related industries (other than 32411)
    32411 Petroleum refining
    325    Chemicals and allied products (other than
           325188, 325211, 32512, or 325311)
    32512 Industrial organic chemicals
    325188 Industrial Inorganic Chemicals
    325211 Plastics materials and resins
    325311 Nitrogenous fertilizers
    326    Rubber and miscellaneous plastic products
    327    Stone, clay, glass, and concrete products (other than 32731)
    32731 Cement, hydraulic
    331    Primary metal industries (other than 331111 or 331312)
    331111 Blast furnaces and steel mills
    331312 Primary aluminum
    332    Fabricated metal products, except machinery and transportation equipment
    333    Industrial and commercial equipment and components except computer equipment
    3345 Measuring, analyzing, and controlling instruments, photographic, medical, and optical goods,
           watches and clocks
    335    Electronic and other electrical equipment and components except computer equipment
    336    Transportation equipment
    337    Furniture and fixtures
    339    Miscellaneous manufacturing industries




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                Page 23
    Transportation and Public Utilities

    22     Electric, gas, and sanitary services
    2212 Natural gas transmission
    2213 Water supply
    22131 Irrigation systems
    22132 Sewerage systems
    481    Transportation by air
    482    Railroad transportation
    483    Water transportation
    484    Motor freight transportation and warehousing
    485    Local and suburban transit and interurban highway passenger transport
    486    Pipelines, except natural gas
    487    Transportation services
    491    United States Postal Service
    513    Communications
    562212 Refuse systems

    Wholesale Trade

    421 to 422

    Retail Trade

    441 to 454

    Finance, Insurance, and Real Estate

    521 to 533

    Services

    512        Motion pictures
    514        Business services
               514199 Miscellaneous services
    541        Legal services
    561        Engineering, accounting, research, management, and related services
    611        Education services
    622        Health services
    624        Social services
    712        Museums, art galleries, and botanical and zoological gardens
    713        Amusement and recreation services
    721        Hotels
    811        Miscellaneous repair services
    8111       Automotive repair, services, and parking
    812        Personal services
    813        Membership organizations
    814        Private households




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                      Page 24
    Public Administration

    92

    Multiple Survey Programs‐ Small Scale PV Solar Estimation of Generation
    Monthly generation from small scale PV solar resources is an estimation of the generation produced
    from PV solar resources and not the results of a data collection effort for generation directly, with the
    exception of “Third Party Owned” or (TPO) solar installations which has direct data collection. TPO data
    however is not comprehensive. TPOs do not operate in every state, TPO collected data is not a large
    portion of the estimated amount, and the data has been collected for limited period of time. The
    generation estimate is based on data collected for PV solar capacity.

    Capacity of PV solar resources is collected directly from respondents. These data are collected on several
    EIA forms and from several types of respondents. Monthly data for net‐metered PV solar capacity is
    reported on the Form EIA‐826. Form EIA‐826 is a cutoff sample drawn from the annual survey Form EIA‐
    861 which collects this data from all respondents. Using data from both of these surveys we have a
    regression model to impute for the non‐sampled monthly capacity.

    The survey instruments collect solar net metering capacity from reporting utilities by state and customer
    class. There are four customer classes: residential, commercial, industrial and transportation.
    However, the estimation process included only the residential, commercial and industrial customers.1
    Data for these customer classes were further classified by U.S. Census Regions, to ensure adequate
    number of customer observations in for each estimation group.

    Estimation Model: The total PV capacity reported by utilities in the annual EIA‐861 survey is the single
    primary input (regressor) to the monthly estimation of PV capacity by state. The model tested for each
    Census Region was of the form:

                yi 2015,m   1xi2013  wi 1 / 2 ei , where

                            xi2013 is the ith utility’s 2013 (or the last published year) solar PV capacity

                            yi2015,m is the ith utility’s month m, 2015 (or the current year) reported solar PV
                                      capacity

                            wi is the weight factor, which is the inverse of xi 2013



                            1 is effectively the growth rate of reported month m solar PV capacity
                           ei is the error term
    The model checks for outliers and removes them from the regression equation inputs. The model
    calculates RSEs by sector, state, census region, and US total. Once we have imputed for all of the

U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                                   Page 25
    monthly net‐metered PV solar capacity we add to total net metered capacity, the PV solar capacity
    collected on the Form EIA‐861 for distributed and dispersed resources that are not net metered.

    We use a second model to estimate the generation using this capacity as an input. The original
    methodology was developed for the “Annual Energy Outlook” based on our “NEMS” modelled
    projections several years ago. The original method underwent a calibration project designed to develop
    PV production levels for the NEMS projections consistent with simulations of a National Renewable
    Energy Laboratory model called PVWatts, which is itself embedded in PC software under the umbrella of
    the NREL’s System Advisor Model (SAM).

    The PVWatts simulations require, panel azimuth orientations and tilts, something that the NEMS
    projections do not include. Call the combinations of azimuths and tilts “orientations.” The orientation
    and solar insolation (specific to a location) have a direct effect on the PV production level. The
    calibration project selected the 100 largest population Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSAs) and relied
    on weights derived from orientation data from California Solar Initiative dataset to develop typical
    outputs for each of the 100 MSAs. It then was expanded from an annual estimate to a monthly
    estimate. A listing of the MSAs are included in Appendix 1.

    Using Form EIA‐861 data for service territories, which lists the counties that each electric distribution
    company (EDC) provides service, and NREL solar insolation data by county a simple average of insolation
    values by EDC is calculated.

    Using the estimation model, we produce by utility, by state and by sector an estimate of generation. All
    the utilities’’ capacity and generation estimates are summed by state and sector and a KWh/KW rate by
    state and sector is calculated.

    Capacity from the Form EIA‐860 that is net metered is subtracted from the total capacity by state and
    sector as well as the capacity reported on the EIA‐826 from TPOs, resulting in a new “net” capacity
    amount. This capacity amount is multiplied by the KWh/KW rate to produce the non‐TPO generation
    estimate and then it is added to the TPO reported sales to ultimate customers from the EIA‐826 to
    obtain a final estimate for generation and a blended KWh/KW rate is calculated. The estimate for
    generation is aggregated by US census regions and US totals. The RSEs for capacity are checked for level
    of error and if they pass, the summary data by state, U.S. census region and U.S. total are reported in
    the EPM.

    Appendix 2 contains a flow diagram of the data inputs, data quality control checks and data analysis
    required to perform this estimation.




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                     Page 26
    Appendix 1‐ MSAs

    TMY3 (1991-2005) Weather Stations by MSA
    Site        Weather Location                                  MSA
    1           USA NY New York Central Park Obs.                 New York‐Newark‐Jersey City, NY‐NJ‐PA MSA
    2           USA CA Los Angeles Intl Airport                   Los Angeles‐Long Beach‐Anaheim, CA MSA
    3           USA IL Chicago Midway Airport                     Chicago‐Naperville‐Elgin, IL‐IN‐WI MSA
    4           USA TX Dallas‐fort Worth Intl Airport             Dallas‐Fort Worth‐Arlington, TX MSA
    5           USA TX Houston Bush Intercontinental              Houston‐The Woodlands‐Sugar Land, TX MSA
    6           USA PA Philadelphia Int’l Airport                 Philadelphia‐Camden‐Wilmington, PA‐NJ‐DE‐MD MSA
    7           USA VA Washington Dc Reagan Airport               Washington‐Arlington‐Alexandria, DC‐VA‐MD‐WV MSA
    8           USA FL Miami Intl Airport                         Miami‐Fort Lauderdale‐West Palm Beach, FL MSA
    9           USA GA Atlanta Hartsfield Intl Airport            Atlanta‐Sandy Springs‐Roswell, GA MSA
    10          USA MA Boston Logan Int'l Airport                 Boston‐Cambridge‐Newton, MA‐NH MSA
    11          USA CA San Francisco Intl Airport                 San Francisco–Oakland–Hayward, CA MSA
    12          USA AZ Phoenix Sky Harbor Intl Airport            Phoenix‐Mesa‐Scottsdale, AZ MSA
    13          USA CA Riverside Municipal Airport                Riverside‐San Bernardino‐Ontario, CA MSA
    14          USA MI Detroit City Airport                       Detroit‐Warren‐Dearborn, MI MSA
    15          USA WA Seattle Seattle‐Tacoma Intl Airport        Seattle‐Tacoma‐Bellevue, WA MSA
    16          USA MN Minneapolis‐St. Paul Int'l Arp             Minneapolis‐St. Paul‐Bloomington, MN‐WI MSA
    17          USA CA San Diego Lindbergh Field                  San Diego‐Carlsbad, CA MSA
    18          USA FL Tampa Int’l Airport                        Tampa‐St. Petersburg‐Clearwater, FL MSA
    19          USA MO St Louis Lambert Int'l Airport             St. Louis, MO‐IL MSA
    20          USA MD Baltimore‐Washington Int'l Airport         Baltimore‐Columbia‐Towson, MD MSA
    21          USA CO Denver Centennial [Golden ‐ NREL]          Denver‐Aurora‐Lakewood, CO MSA
    22          USA PA Pittsburgh Allegheny Co Airport            Pittsburgh, PA MSA
    23          USA NC Charlotte Douglas Intl Airport             Charlotte‐Concord‐Gastonia, NC‐SC MSA
    24          USA OR Portland Hillsboro                         Portland‐Vancouver‐Hillsboro, OR‐WA MSA
    25          USA TX San Antonio Intl Airport                   San Antonio‐New Braunfels, TX MSA
    26          USA FL Orlando Intl Airport                       Orlando‐Kissimmee‐Sanford, FL MSA
    27          USA CA Sacramento Executive Airport               Sacramento–Roseville–Arden‐Arcade, CA MSA
    28          USA OH Cincinnati Municipal Airport               Cincinnati, OH‐KY‐IN MSA
    29          USA OH Cleveland Hopkins Intl Airport             Cleveland‐Elyria, OH MSA
    30          USA MO Kansas City Int'l Airport                  Kansas City, MO‐KS MSA
    31          USA NV Las Vegas McCarran Intl Airport            Las Vegas‐Henderson‐Paradise, NV MSA
    32          USA OH Columbus Port Columbus Intl A              Columbus, OH MSA
    33          USA IN Indianapolis Intl Airport                  Indianapolis‐Carmel‐Anderson, IN MSA
    34          USA CA San Jose Intl Airport                      San Jose‐Sunnyvale‐Santa Clara, CA MSA
    35          USA TX Austin Mueller Municipal Airport           Austin‐Round Rock, TX MSA
    36          USA TN Nashville Int’l Airport                    Nashville‐Davidson–Murfreesboro–Franklin, TN MSA



U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                                      Page 27
    37          USA VA Norfolk Int’l Airport                      Virginia Beach‐Norfolk‐Newport News, VA‐NC MSA
    38          USA RI Providence T F Green State                 Providence‐Warwick, RI‐MA MSA
    39          USA WI Milwaukee Mitchell Intl Airport            Milwaukee‐Waukesha‐West Allis, WI MSA
    40          USA FL Jacksonville Craig                         Jacksonville, FL MSA
    41          USA TN Memphis Int’l Airport                      Memphis, TN‐MS‐AR MSA
    42          USA OK Oklahoma City Will Rogers                  Oklahoma City, OK MSA
    43          USA KY Louisville Bowman Field                    Louisville/Jefferson County, KY‐IN MSA
    44          USA VA Richmond Int’l Airport                     Richmond, VA MSA
    45          USA LA New Orleans Alvin Callender                New Orleans‐Metairie, LA MSA
    46          USA CT Hartford Bradley Intl Airport              Hartford‐West Hartford‐East Hartford, CT MSA
    47          USA NC Raleigh Durham Int’l                       Raleigh, NC MSA
    48          USA UT Salt Lake City Int'l Airport               Salt Lake City, UT MSA
    49          USA AL Birmingham Municipal Airport               Birmingham‐Hoover, AL MSA
    50          USA NY Buffalo Niagara Intl Airport               Buffalo‐Cheektowaga‐Niagara Falls, NY MSA
    51          USA NY Rochester Greater Rochester                Rochester, NY MSA
    52          USA MI Grand Rapids Kent County Int'l Airport     Grand Rapids‐Wyoming, MI MSA
    53          USA AZ Tucson Int’l Airport                       Tucson, AZ MSA
    54          USA HI Honolulu Intl Airport                      Urban Honolulu, HI MSA
    55          USA OK Tulsa Int’l Airport                        Tulsa, OK MSA
    56          USA CA Fresno Yosemite Intl Airport               Fresno, CA MSA
    57          USA CT Bridgeport Sikorsky Memorial               Bridgeport‐Stamford‐Norwalk, CT MSA
    58          USA MA Worchester Regional Airport                Worcester, MA‐CT MSA
    59          USA NM Albuquerque Intl Airport                   Albuquerque, NM MSA
    60          USA NE Omaha Eppley Airfield                      Omaha‐Council Bluffs, NE‐IA MSA
    61          USA NY Albany County Airport                      Albany‐Schenectady‐Troy, NY MSA
    62          USA CA Bakersfield Meadows Field                  Bakersfield, CA MSA
    63          USA CT New Haven Tweed Airport                    New Haven‐Milford, CT MSA
    64          USA TN Knoxville McGhee Tyson Airport             Knoxville, TN MSA
    65          USA SC Greenville Downtown Airport                Greenville‐Anderson‐Mauldin, SC MSA
    66          USA CA Oxnard Airport                             Oxnard‐Thousand Oaks‐Ventura, CA MSA
    67          USA TX El Paso Int’l Airport                      El Paso, TX MSA
    68          USA PA Allentown Lehigh Valley Intl               Allentown‐Bethlehem‐Easton, PA‐NJ MSA
    69          USA LA Baton Rouge Ryan Airport                   Baton Rouge, LA MSA
    70          USA TX McCallen Miller Intl Airport               McAllen‐Edinburg‐Mission, TX MSA
    71          USA OH Dayton Int’l Airport                       Dayton, OH MSA
    72          USA SC Columbia Metro Airport                     Columbia, SC MSA
    73          USA NC Greensboro Piedmont Triad Int’l            Greensboro‐High Point, NC MSA
                Airport

    74          USA FL Sarasota Bradenton                         North Port‐Sarasota‐Bradenton, FL MSA
    75          USA AR Little Rock Adams Field                    Little Rock‐North Little Rock‐Conway, AR MSA
    76          USA SC Charleston Intl Airport                    Charleston‐North Charleston, SC MSA
    77          USA OH Akron Akron‐canton Reg. Airport            Akron, OH MSA
    78          USA CA Stockton Metropolitan Airport              Stockton‐Lodi, CA MSA

U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                                    Page 28
    79          USA CO Colorado Springs Muni Airport              Colorado Springs, CO MSA
    80          USA NY Syracuse Hancock Int'l Airport             Syracuse, NY MSA
    81          USA FL Fort Myers Page Field                      Cape Coral‐Fort Myers, FL MSA
    82          USA NC Winston‐Salem Reynolds Airport             Winston‐Salem, NC MSA
    83          USA ID Boise Air Terminal                         Boise City, ID MSA
    84          USA KS Wichita Mid‐continent Airport              Wichita, KS MSA
    85          USA WI Madison Dane Co Regional Airport           Madison, WI MSA
    86          USA MA Worchester Regional Airport                Springfield, MA MSA
    87          USA FL Lakeland Linder Regional Airport           Lakeland‐Winter Haven, FL MSA
    88          USA UT Ogden Hinkley Airport                      Ogden‐Clearfield, UT MSA
    89          USA OH Toledo Express Airport                     Toledo, OH MSA
    90          USA FL Daytona Beach Intl Airport                 Deltona‐Daytona Beach‐Ormond Beach, FL MSA
    91          USA IA Des Moines Intl Airport                    Des Moines‐West Des Moines, IA MSA
    92          USA GA Augusta Bush Field                         Augusta‐Richmond County, GA‐SC MSA
    93          USA MS Jackson Int’l Airport                      Jackson, MS MSA
    94          USA UT Provo Muni                                 Provo‐Orem, UT MSA
    95          USA PA Wilkes‐Barre Scranton Intl Airport         Scranton–Wilkes‐Barre–Hazleton, PA MSA
    96          USA PA Harrisburg Capital City Airport            Harrisburg‐Carlisle, PA MSA
    97          USA OH Youngstown Regional Airport                Youngstown‐Warren‐Boardman, OH‐PA MSA
    98          USA FL Melbourne Regional Airport                 Palm Bay‐Melbourne‐Titusville, FL MSA
    99          USA TN Chattanooga Lovell Field Airport           Chattanooga, TN‐GA MSA
    100         USA WA Spokane Int’l Airport                      Spokane‐Spokane Valley, WA MSA




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                                Page 29
                           Appendix 2 – Flow diagram of data sources and analysis




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                     Page 30
    1 The basic technique employed is described in the paper “Model‐Based Sampling and Inference,” on the EIA website.

    Additional references can be found on the InterStat website (http://interstat.statjournals.net/). See the following sources:
    Knaub, J.R., Jr. (1999a), “Using Prediction‐Oriented Software for Survey Estimation,” InterStat, October 1999,
    http://interstat.statjournals.net/; Knaub, J.R. Jr. (1999b), “Model‐Based Sampling, Inference and Imputation,” EIA web site:
    http://www.eia.gov/cneaf/electricity/forms/eiawebme.pdf; Knaub, J.R., Jr. (2005), “Classical Ratio Estimator,” InterStat, October
    2005, http://interstat.statjournals.net/; Knaub, J.R., Jr. (2007a), “Cutoff Sampling and Inference,” InterStat, April 2007,
    http://interstat.statjournals.net/; Knaub, J.R., Jr. (2008), “Cutoff Sampling.” Definition in Encyclopedia of Survey Research Methods,
    Editor: Paul J. Lavrakas, Sage, to appear; Knaub, J.R., Jr. (2000), “Using Prediction‐Oriented Software for Survey Estimation ‐ Part
    II: Ratios of Totals,” InterStat, June 2000, http://interstat.statjournals.net/; Knaub, J.R., Jr. (2001), “Using Prediction‐Oriented
    Software for Survey Estimation ‐ Part III: Full‐Scale Study of Variance and Bias,” InterStat, June 2001,
    http://interstat.statjournals.net/.
    2 See the following sources: Bahillo, A. et al. Journal of Energy Resources Technology, “NOx and N2O Emissions during Fluidized

    Bed Combustion of Leather Wastes.” Volume 128, Issue 2, June 2006. pp. 99‐103; U.S. Energy Information Administration.
    Renewable Energy Annual 2004. “Average Heat Content of Selected Biomass Fuels.” Washington, DC, 2005; Penn State
    Agricultural College Agricultural and Biological Engineering and Council for Solid Waste Solutions. Garth, J. and Kowal, P.
    Resource Recovery, Turning Waste into Energy, University Park, PA, 1993; Utah State University Recycling Center Frequently
    Asked Questions. Published at http://www.usu.edu/recycle/faq.htm. Accessed December 2006.
    3 Biogenic components include newsprint, paper, containers and packaging, leather, textiles, yard trimmings, food wastes, and

    wood. Non‐biogenic components include plastics, rubber and other miscellaneous non‐biogenic waste.




U.S. Energy Information Administration | Electric Power Monthly                                                               Page 31
